Legislators are frequently asked by their constituents to be advocates for community capital projects and to assist in obtaining state funding, typically through tax-exempt bond funds, for those projects. This guide, developed by the Ohio Cultural Facilities Commission, is a resource to assist in identifying projects that are in a position to benefit from the state's involvement and to explain how funding through the Commission works.
The "Key Questions for Legislators about Community Capital Project Funding Requests" is an important section of this guide. The staff of the Commission has undertaken research to examine the methods and requirements used by other states, local groups, and funding institutions to assess and fund community capital projects. While we learned that there is variation in funding mechanisms, we also learned that the need for careful assessment before a project is funded is held across the board. Financial health, good planning, and responsiveness to the community were consistently identified as key issues in determining if a project would be a long term success.
From this research and the Commission's staff experience, the Commission developed these questions to help legislative staff and community leaders determine whether a proposed project would benefit the community, and would benefit from a state appropriation in an upcoming capital appropriations bill. If these questions can be answered affirmatively, a project is likely to succeed. By extension, the state of Ohio is better able to protect public funds and ensure successful community facilities when these questions can be answered before funds are expended on any community project.
Meetings with individual members of the Legislature have reinforced the need for the Commission to develop a project pre-assessment tool that would answer the "six key questions." This tool, when completed at the legislator's request by a project sponsor, helps distinguish the projects that will most benefit from state funding, and those that may have difficulty meeting appropriate requirements for the expenditure of public moneys.
Ohio is fortunate to be home to many world-class cultural facilities. Public investment in such community projects is important because they help to bolster community development.
Cultural facilities, historical sites and sports facilities all play a role in adding value to Ohio's communities when they are part of plans focused on the creative economy, education, community revitalization, and tourism. Well-planned cultural, historical and sports facilities:
A December 2001 editorial by the Cincinnati Post declared that the visual arts are "big contributors to the regional economy and its quality of life."
Results of a survey by the U.S. Department of Commerce's Bureau of Economic Analysis provide some numbers that back this up. The study found that $10 billion was spent on the arts by U.S. consumers in 1997. That is 1.6 times more than what was spent on movies and sporting events. Another study by the Community Partnership for Arts and Culture showed that the annual economic impact of the arts in Cleveland alone is $1.3 billion.
The Governor's Sports Facilities Task Force, which presented a report to the Governor and General Assembly in 1995, found that long-term, targeted economic benefits can stem from properly planned sports facilities. Benefits result from economic activity that occurs in close proximity to facilities that are part of a well-conceived development plan.
According to the report, research shows that sports facilities located in central, downtown sites near existing businesses and other attractions generate the most economic impact.
Less tangible benefits, the Task Force concluded, come from the entertainment and recreational value of professional sports and the media attention associated with sports teams and events.
The General Assembly and Governor determine the Cultural Facilities Commission's project docket. All of the projects that are funded through the agency are assigned to it in the state's biennial capital budgets.
Unlike agencies such as the Ohio Arts Council, Department of Development, and Department of Natural Resources, which have selection programs to determine the distribution of grant dollars, the Commission does not have discretionary control over decisions regarding capital funds.
Community leaders and project sponsors are responsible for approaching their area's Representatives and Senators in the General Assembly to request that particular projects be considered for state funding. The Commission can assist legislators, upon request, by conducting a pre-assessment of a potential project sponsor's planning and to determine eligibility to receive state funds. Legislators interested in project pre-assessments may contact Jessica Fagan, the agency's communications manager, at 614-752-2770 or jfagan@culture.ohio.gov.
Projects that are successful in securing support are appropriated a specific amount of funds in a line item in the capital budget. Eligible projects are then assigned to the Commission in the capital bill for funding oversight.
The Commission's role with community capital projects is to establish and implement operational policies and oversight mechanisms to ensure that the public funds entrusted to our care are spent properly. We protect state interests by verifying that each project has significant community support and a solid management plan.
The General Assembly and Governor assign projects to the Commission in the state's biennial capital improvement bills. Since 1988, more than $485 million has been appropriated for more than 300 projects of various sizes and complexities. The Commission partners with non-profit groups and local governments on these community projects. The projects are spread among 65 Ohio counties.
The Commission does not have discretionary control over decisions regarding capital funds. Likewise, the Commission does not play a formal role in deciding which projects to fund, but can assist communities and state officials in determining project eligibility upon the request of a member of the Legislature or legislative staff. A Project Planning and Assessment Guide is available for use by potential project sponsors when considering and planning a capital project. Commission staff can provide a copy of the Guide upon request, and it is also available at www.culture.ohio.gov.
After projects are assigned to the Commission, the Commission staff works with communities and project sponsors to assist them through the required processes. These include project management assistance, funding administration and contract oversight. The Commission's processes, standards, and legal agreements are detailed in the Project Sponsor Resource Guide, which is sent to all organizations that receive capital appropriations through the Commission, and is available at www.culture.ohio.gov.
Careful planning and supervision by the Commission additionally help maximize the impact of the state's investment over time by ensuring the projects, once completed, will operate successfully. This protects the state from future costs and liabilities that result from investing in projects that may fail.
The Commission's role with state historical facilities is slightly different from its role with cultural facilities. While the state actually owns most of these sites, the Ohio Historical Society (a non-profit entity) is contracted to operate and maintain them on the state's behalf. The General Assembly and Governor selected the Commission to provide supervision for the state historical facilities projects and serve as a bond-funding agent for them. The society is not eligible to receive state bond funds directly, because it is not a government agency.
The Ohio Cultural Facilities Commission is a state agency that helps enhance the quality of life for Ohioans by improving the state's cultural facilities. The Commission ensures wise stewardship of capital improvement funds appropriated by the General Assembly and Governor for planning, construction, renovation and expansion projects at Ohio's non-profit theaters, museums, historical sites and publicly owned professional sports venues.
The statutory role of the Ohio Cultural Facilities Commission is defined in Chapter 3383 of the Ohio Revised Code. The Commission was established in 1988 as the Ohio Arts Facilities Commission. Since its inception, the expanding role and responsibilities of the Commission have prompted the Legislature twice to change the name. In 1995 the name was changed to the Ohio Arts & Sports Facilities Commission.
Most recently, in 2004, the name was changed to the Ohio Cultural Facilities Commission in order to appropriately convey the broad nature of the Commission's work.
The Commission consists of 12 members; nine voting and three non-voting. The Governor appoints the nine voting members, and in accordance with statute, these members are selected from various geographic areas of the state. The Commission also includes three non-voting, ex-officio members, including the staff director of the Ohio Arts Council plus two legislative members, one each appointed by the Senate President and House Speaker. To view the current roster of Commission members, please visit www.culture.ohio.gov.
The Commission staff is happy to provide assistance to legislators and/or project sponsors preparing to make capital bill requests. Kathleen M. Fox, FASLA, has served as executive director of the Commission since 1993. Jessica Fagan, the agency's communications manager, acts as the primary legislative liaison. Meetings and/or phone calls can be arranged by contacting Jessica at 614-752-2770 or jfagan@culture.ohio.gov.
Designed for non-profit organizations considering a community capital project, the Project Planning and Assessment Guide offers information and resources to assist organizations with detailed and accurate project planning, and leads them through the "key questions" that will help them assess their project's viability as a candidate for a capital appropriation.
The Project Sponsor Resource Guide is provided to all projects that receive a bond-funded capital appropriation through the Commission. The Guide assists local project sponsors through the typical process to release state-appropriated funds, including detailed information on meeting project standards, seeking Commission approvals, managing construction, and receiving reimbursements.
These and other resources are available in PDF format on the Commission's website at www.culture.ohio.gov. Bound copies can be obtained by contacting Jessica Fagan, the Commission's communications manager, at 614-752-2770 or jfagan@culture.ohio.gov.
After appropriations are made through the biennial capital improvements bill, projects that are assigned to the Ohio Cultural Facilities Commission must satisfy a series of requirements set forth by the Ohio Revised Code, capital bill, Commission and bond issuer (Treasurer of State) before we can release the appropriated funds to them. The requirements vary based on project (cultural or sports), funding type (bond or General Revenue Fund), and project type (planning or construction).
Standards for Bond-Funded Construction Projects at Cultural Facilities
By statute (Ohio Revised Code Section 3383), "Ohio cultural facilities" include facilities for the public presentation of visual and performing arts, museums for the presentation of science, technology and transportation, local historical facilities, and facilities for education and training in the arts and design.
While this is not a complete list, the requirements for bond-funded cultural facilities projects include the following:
The property must be used for the presentation or making available of "culture" to the public, as described above;
In addition, those cultural facilities receiving bond funds for construction projects must enter into legal agreements with the Commission as detailed below:
After the above requirements are met, the Commission expends funds to project sponsors on a reimbursement basis for locally administered projects. On the occasions that a project is administered by the State Architect's Office, the Commission pays contractor invoices directly.
Standards for General Revenue Funded Construction Projects at Cultural Facilities
General Revenue Fund (GRF) construction projects at cultural facilities are subject to fewer requirements than those receiving bond funds. Primarily, these requirements include:
Normally, one basic agreement is entered into for these projects:
Standards for Planning Projects at Cultural Facilities
Sometimes communities receive appropriations for planning and feasibility studies. These projects can be assigned to the Commission.
However, because bond funds are intended for capital improvements that have a long useful life, GRF grant agreements are the preferred funding method for planning situations.
Requirements for GRF-funded cultural facilities planning projects are greatly simplified—project sponsors only are required to enter into a GRF grant agreement with the Commission.
Standards for Bond Funded Construction Projects at Sports Facilities
By statute (Ohio Revised Code Section 3383), an "Ohio sports facility" is defined as all or a portion of a stadium, arena, tennis facility, motorsports complex, or other facility in Ohio that serves as a venue for motorsports events, professional tennis tournaments, or events of one or more major or minor league professional sports teams.
While this is not a complete list, the requirements for bond-funded sports facilities projects include the following:
In addition, those sports facilities receiving bond funds for construction projects must enter into legal agreements with the Commission as detailed below:
Requirements for General Revenue Funded Construction Projects at Sports Facilities
While this is not a complete list, the requirements for General Revenue Fund (GRF) construction projects at sports facilities include the following:
One agreement typically is required for these projects:
Standards for Planning Projects for Sports Facilities
Sometimes communities receive appropriations for planning and feasibility studies. These projects can be assigned to the Commission.
However, the Ohio Revised Code specifies certain requirements to be met prior to the expenditure of state funds for sports facilities. If a planning project is undertaken for a sports facility, special language should be attached to the appropriation in the capital bill by the Legislature. The Commission staff can assist legislators with examples of such language from prior capital bills.
GRF-funded sports facilities planning projects typically are required to enter into one agreement with the Commission—a GRF grant agreement.
The Ohio Cultural Facilities Commission has developed a best practices model for appropriating and managing funding for the state's community capital improvement projects. The following questions are designed to help legislators determine whether a proposed project would benefit the community, and would benefit from a state appropriation in an upcoming capital appropriations bill.
How can a facility receive funding from the Commission?
The General Assembly and Governor determine the Commission's project docket. All of the projects that are funded through the Commission are assigned to it in the state's biennial capital budgets. The Commission does not have discretionary control over decisions regarding capital funds.
What should project sponsors do to be considered for a capital appropriation from the state?
Community leaders and project sponsors are responsible for approaching their area's representatives in the General Assembly to request that particular projects be considered for state funding. There is no official application process, although the Commission offers a project pre-assessment service when requested by a legislator.
Can a for-profit organization receive state funding via the Commission?
Only 501(c)(3) organizations incorporated in Ohio and local Ohio governments (usually a city or county government) may receive funding from the Commission.
What types of facilities can be funded through the Commission?
By law, "Ohio cultural facilities" include facilities for the public presentation of visual and performing arts, cultural education facilities, museums for the presentation of science, technology and transportation, local historical facilities and state historical facilities.
"Ohio sports facilities" include all or a portion of a publicly-owned stadium, arena, tennis facility motorsports complex, or other facility in Ohio that serves as a venue for either motorsports events, professional tennis tournaments, or events of one or more major or minor league professional sports teams.
Facilities that do not fit these definitions may not be eligible to receive funding through the Commission.
What types of projects can be funded through the Commission?
Examples of eligible projects include new construction, renovations, restorations, expansions, exhibits and planning/feasibility studies.
The Commission cannot fund projects in phases unless the result at the end of each phase is an operable facility.
The Commission typically does not provide site acquisition costs for cultural facilities.
The Ohio Revised Code prohibits the Commission from paying for site acquisition for sports facilities.
Likewise, the statute prevents the Commission for paying for operating costs at cultural and sports facilities.
Do other agencies offer grant opportunities for operating expenses?
Commission funds may only be used to pay for construction-related costs, and in certain instances, facility planning. The Ohio Arts Council (OAC), a separate state agency, does award grants to arts organizations for operational/programming purposes. For more information, contact OAC at 614-466-2613 or visit the agency web site at www.oac.state.oh.us.
How much money can a project receive from the state?
Cultural facilities are eligible to receive state funding up to two-thirds of the total project cost. The remaining amount must be raised from local government funding or private funding. In other words, for every $2 of state funding, there must be $1 in local resources. This is referred to as the "local match." However, in practice, the local funding is usually significantly more than the required minimum.
The cost of sports facilities must be at least 85 percent locally funded. The state may contribute up to a maximum of 15 percent of the initial estimated cost of construction, excluding site acquisition.
In all cases, the statutory maximums for state funds should not be viewed as "entitlements" of anticipated levels of funding from the state. All such funding is subject to appropriations by the Legislature.
What is considered an appropriate "local match?"
For cultural facilities, the local match can include the value of the project site or facility; written fundraising pledges to a capital campaign; corporate, foundation, or local or federal government grants; certification of cash on hand or in a capital fund account; and/or new funds committed to an endowment for the operation and maintenance of the facility; or any combination of these.
For sports facilities, only funds for construction-related costs are eligible as a local match.
What activities are included as "construction costs?"
"Construction" includes demolition, reconstruction, alteration, renovation, remodeling, enlargement, exhibits, site improvements, and related equipping and furnishing. Under certain limited circumstances, professional design fees for the project may also be eligible; please contact the Commission to discuss these limited circumstances.
What happens if a project receives a state appropriation through the Commission but has not yet raised the required local match?
While the Commission encourages project sponsors to have local funding sources in place, it is not required prior to the appropriation. State law, however, does require the Commission to confirm community support in the form of a local match before it can expend state funds. In the meantime, while the local sponsor raises the local match, the state funds remain designated for the project for which they were appropriated. Typically, any unexpended funds are re-appropriated over future biennia, unless specifically changed by the General Assembly and approved by the Governor in a capital reappropriations bill.
Is it true that the Commission requires that the state obtain a leasehold interest in projects that it funds?
Projects that received bond funds issued prior to July 2005 did have to sign a lease; however, for projects funded with bonds issued by the Treasurer of State (July 2005 or later), the state and the local project sponsor enter into a Cooperative Use Agreement (CUA). Through the CUA, the state ensures the continuing use of the facility for cultural purposes for the term of the bonds used to fund the project (typically 15 years), and agrees that the local sponsor controls all day-to-day facility operations. This differs from projects funded by bonds prior to July 2005 because it eliminates the requirement for a real property lease.
Neither cultural nor sports facilities projects that receive General Revenue Funds (GRF) are required to enter into Cooperative Use Agreements; rather, a GRF Grant Agreement is used instead.
Does the state serve as construction administrator for Commission projects, or can the local project sponsor do so?
Local project sponsors may serve as their own construction administrators, provided they can demonstrate to the Commission their capability to do so. Locally managed construction can provide project sponsors with a level of flexibility and adaptability that is beneficial when overseeing complex construction projects.
If local construction administration is not desired, or not granted by the Commission, construction administration can be handled through the State Architect's Office.
Sports facilities are required, by statute, to have construction administration provided by a local governmental agency.
If a project does receive funding in a capital bill line item through the Commission, how soon will the sponsor receive the funds from the state?
The timing of payments/reimbursements is contingent upon required Commission approvals and varies from project to project.
Prior to the expenditure of funds, the project sponsor must present the project to Commission members at a quarterly meeting. The members of the Commission then must vote upon resolutions that:
For projects that have not yet met all of the requirements to receive state funds, a memorandum of understanding agreement may be entered into immediately after a Commission meeting where certain preliminary approvals have been made by the Commission. The memorandum of understanding documents the intent of the parties and details the remaining requirements that need to be met prior to the Commission's approval for the expenditure of state funds.
For some projects receiving a state appropriation of fifty thousand dollars or less, the Commission may delegate to its executive director the authority to approve the above items without appearing before the Commission.
For projects that are administered locally (see previous question/answer), the sponsor submits paid invoices to the Commission for review and approval. The Commission then processes payment of approved invoices on a reimbursement basis.
For projects that are administered by the State Architect's Office, the state makes payments to contractors directly.
Are there fees associated with the Commission's oversight of cultural facility projects?
The Commission does not charge any fees for the management of projects assigned to it. However, projects for which construction is administered by the State Architect's Office may be subject to project management fees from that office.
As the Commission does not directly operate the facilities, all rental or usage fees generated at the cultural, sports, and statewide historic facilities are collected by and used by the local project sponsors for facility operation and maintenance.
Can the Commission provide technical assistance to project sponsors even if the project hasn't yet officially received state funding?
The staff of the Commission is happy to provide assistance in reviewing projects for compatibility with this program. To arrange a meeting, contact Jessica Fagan at 614-752-2770 or jfagan@culture.ohio.gov.